Skip to content
Fist of Truth emblem: FOT in red on a yellow starburst FIST OF TRUTH

Fist of Truth

HOW WE FACT-CHECK

We never rate a claim ourselves. A claim gets the Fist of Truth's punch only when one of eight professional fact-checkers rates it false, or, in a Throwback, when the official record proves it false. When nobody has rated it, we show the record and you be the judge.

The Fist of Truth throwing a jab: a right fist in a royal blue FOT sleeve with a red cape

Step by step

HOW A CLAIM GETS THE FIST OF TRUTH.

Every claim the Fist of Truth hits goes through the same five steps. Follow one from the tape to the receipt.

  1. Rated false by one of the eight

    Required

    A professional fact-checker has to rate the claim False, Pants on Fire or Four Pinocchios, or the equivalent. Only these eight count:

    • PolitiFact
    • FactCheck.org
    • The Washington Post Fact Checker
    • AP Fact Check
    • Reuters Fact Check
    • CNN Facts First
    • USA Today Fact Check
    • Lead Stories

    The one exception is a Throwback, a famous claim from history. Its receipt is the official record: the person's own later admission, a court's finding that still stands, an official investigation or the government's own data. Never an op-ed, a book or a news story.

  2. The fact-checkers disagree

    Skipped

    If the fact-checkers disagree on a claim, we leave it alone. No hit, no receipt.

  3. Who said it

    Any party

    “We go after it no matter who it is.” The punch goes to whoever one of the eight rated false, any party, and the formats with no verdict follow any public figure on tape the same way. We log the party of every person we cover, as the record.

  4. The hit follows the rating

    Tap or punch

    The fact-checker's rating sets how hard the Fist of Truth hits. Every hit is a cartoon punch.

    • Mostly False or Three Pinocchios THE TAP Only a light tap, and a MOSTLY FALSE stamp.
    • False THE PUNCH The Fist of Truth throws a cartoon punch.
    • Pants on Fire or Four Pinocchios A BIGGER PUNCH The Fist of Truth hits harder.
  5. The receipt

    Their words

    The receipt prints the fact-check's own numbers, word for word, and names the fact-checker. Then the stamp slams down.

    Every receipt links its source in the video's description, so you can read the whole thing yourself.

    A receipt, explained

    “Save $7,500?”


    • Iowa's 2024 income tax cuts: about $410 in 2025
    • Federal tax cuts: about $3,100 in 2026

    Source: PolitiFact

    Link: in the video's description

    VERDICT: FALSE

The footage

THREE TIERS OF FOOTAGE.

Where the claim on screen comes from, in order of preference.

  1. Tier 1 · Preferred

    OFFICIAL VIDEO

    Official U.S. government video. It is public domain, so it comes first whenever the claim was made on it.

  2. Tier 2

    QUOTE CARD

    When there is no clip, the claim goes on a card: the words verbatim, with the outlet and the date cited.

  3. Tier 3

    SHORT CLIP

    A short clip of the claim itself, usually 15 seconds or less. It is credited on screen while it plays and linked in the description, and it never plays without our setup and our card around it: the receipt, the record or the stop.

    The on-screen credit Clip: KWQC News, Oct. 6, 2026, used for commentary

No verdict

NO RATING, NO VERDICT.

Then vs. Now, Answer the Question, Instant Replay and every unrated stop in Stop the Tape call no verdict: no punch, no stamp, no FALSE. They put the record on screen and hand it to you.

All episodes

THEN VS. NOW

A politician's own dated words, side by side. Then the call is yours.

YOU BE THE JUDGE

ANSWER THE QUESTION

A direct question and the whole answer, played in full. When the answer never comes, we say so.

STILL WAITING.

Stop the Tape

WHEN NOBODY HAS RATED IT.

Stop the Tape follows public figures on tape and stops the tape where the record has something to say. When one of the eight has rated the claim, it gets the punch. When nobody has, we show what is out there and you be the judge.

RATED

One of the eight rated it False, Pants on Fire or Four Pinocchios. It gets the Quick Hit: the punch, the receipt and the stamp. Mostly False gets the light tap.

THE RECORD

The same tape or the official record shows otherwise: a transcript, a court filing or ruling, government data, a bill's text or an official schedule. The card quotes it, named, dated and linked. No punch.

WHAT'S OUT THERE

Sourced information that bears on it: an article from one of the eight, AP or Reuters reporting, or the person's own earlier words, quoted and named. No punch.

THE DODGE

A direct question that gets no answer. We count it the way Answer the Question does: how many times it was asked, and how many times it was answered.

WHO IS IN IT

Public figures, on tape: elected officials, candidates, administration officials and nominees, officials testifying, campaign and party spokespeople, and anyone on a show as a host, anchor, panelist, contributor, strategist, analyst or commentator, paid or not. Creators with large audiences who post political claims count too.

Never private people: private citizens testifying, callers, audience members, voters interviewed on a show and small creators.

THE SOURCES WE ALLOW

Strongest first: the same tape; official records (transcripts, court filings and rulings, government data, bill text, official schedules, published sports records); the person's own earlier words; articles from the eight, even with no rating of this claim; and AP or Reuters reporting, quoted and named.

Never: op-eds, partisan outlets on either side, other commentators, Wikipedia, AI chatbots or anonymous posts.

NO HIT, NO VERDICT WORD, NO STAMP

Without a rating there is no punch, no FALSE, no stamp and no lie counter. The card says what the source says, and Bob adds no fact beyond it. We mock the claim or the move, never the person.

A later rating makes it a Quick Hit. If one of the eight rates the claim afterward, the pinned comment is updated and the claim gets its punch.

The Fist of Truth pointing straight at you, royal blue FOT sleeve and red cape

YOU BE THE JUDGE.

Every Stop the Tape ends here, and then the fine print: The views expressed are solely those of the Fist of Truth. The Fist of Truth is a cartoon fist, who knows all.

The lines we hold

WHAT WE NEVER DO.

Three rules hold for every episode, in every format.

  • CHANGE THEIR WORDS

    A speaker's words are never altered, re-voiced or reordered. Captions are verbatim. A jump cut inside a claim shows a flash and keeps the meaning.

  • MOCK THE PERSON

    We mock the lie, never the person. The Fist of Truth is a cartoon: its punch moves the whole screen and never distorts a face.

  • COVER VOTING PROCEDURES

    We make no content about voting procedures, in any format.

Errors and corrections

KEEP US HONEST.

If a receipt, a caption or a credit looks wrong, write to hello@fistoftruthshow.com with the episode and what you found.

Spotted an error? Tell us
Corrections

CORRECTIONS, PINNED.

When a fact-check or record we cited is revised, we post a correction and pin it on the original. Every one is listed in the log.

The corrections log